Get Ready for a Monster Reversion Trade for the Ages

Get Ready for a Monster Reversion Trade for the Ages

by Lucas Downey All, Big Money Insights Weekly, Stocks

The appetite for stocks is off the charts.

…especially mega-cap tech names.

This has caused market breadth readings to plummet.

But don’t fret because now’s the time to get ready for a monster reversion trade for the Ages.

Let’s face it, if you’re not holding the handful of AI-fueled growth names right now, odds are your portfolio is underperforming.

The good news is that we’ve been all over this trade. Not only did we make the data-driven case that a major ultra-bullish signal is approaching just 6 weeks ago…we also teed up an evidence-rich study suggesting the NASDAQ was ready to explode.

But today I bring better news, this time for the rest of the market.

Turns out, one popular breadth reading is signaling a significant gap between the returns of cap-weighted stocks relative to the rest of the market.

It’s a brow-raising development that rarely comes along.

But here’s the hard-hitting truth: Those unpopular laggards will have their day again…and based on history, it’ll be here a lot sooner than the crowd realizes.

There’s an epic setup for stock pickers coming soon.

Before we get to that powerful study, let’s check in on the overall state of the market.

The Average Stock is Underperforming Major Indices

Money flows reveal the true health of the stock market. When a majority of equities are participating in a rally, breadth is said to be strong.

That is not the case recently as a handful of names are dragging major indexes higher.

Case in point, our trusty Big Money Index (BMI) reveals this truth beautifully. If the BMI is falling, it indicates that the total number of stocks getting sold is higher than the number getting bought.

Said another way, the average stock is falling behind:

Big Money Index (BMI) | MAPsignals

Now, we know this because at MAPsignals we can easily see the names getting accumulated each day.

As stated last week, massive money has been flowing into mega-cap semiconductors for months.

But there are other ways to visualize the dichotomy in equities. One look at a few different baskets of the S&P 500, points to the massive underperformance of the average stock.

Below we can see how the top 50 stocks in the S&P 500 (XLG ETF) have gained +22.53% in 2024.

That easily beats the S&P 500’s (SPY ETF) jump of +15.76% and dramatically crushes the S&P 500 equal weight basket (RSP ETF) YTD performance of +5.17%:

But there’s one other way to note the major market dichotomy.

When you look at a ratio chart of the S&P 500 equal weight basket (RSP ETF) relative to the S&P 500 (SPY ETF), you’ll see that we’re sitting at the weakest breadth point since 2008.

Currently the RSP/SPY ratio sits at nearly 30%.

If you want to rattle the bear cages, show them this free-falling chart:

RSP-SPY ratio has fallen to levels unseen since GFC | TradingView | MAPsignals

This ratio chart has gotten a lot of traction in the media lately as pundits proclaim this relative weakness is uber bearish for markets.

Afterall, the last few times we approached these levels was ugly periods for markets: 30% ratio reading in the depths of 2008 and 2009, a 32% reading during the COVID crash of 2020, and the 30% readings found today.

I’ll be honest, I almost fell for the bait.

That is, until I studied history. And she had one message that you need to hear: Get ready for a monster reversion trade for the ages!

Get Ready for a Monster Reversion Trade for the Ages

MAPsignals is all about bringing you evidence-based research that flies in the face of the talking-heads in the media.

Before you bailout on your underperforming stocks, have a look at the following pieces of evidence suggesting you should sit tight.

And if you’re bold, start buying the beaten down dogs…

I went back and singled out all days when the RSP/SPY ratio fell below 32%. Basically, I needed to understand what we should expect for stocks going forward.

As a reminder, the 32% threshold amounts to 201 trading dates that triggered during the Global Financial Crisis lows, the COVID crash lows, and the relative lows seen recently.

Here’s what happened next. The S&P 500 (SPY ETF) did just fine. But the S&P 500 Equal Weight Fund (RSP ETF) was spectacular.

When the RSP/SPY ratio fell to 32% or lower since 2007:

  • 6-months later the S&P 500 jumped 13% while the S&P 500 Equal Weight basket soared 24.1%
  • 12-months later clocked gains of 29.1% for SPY and 47.1% gains for RSP
  • 24-months after saw SPY jump 48.6% and RSP catapult 78%
S&p 500 ETF Forward Return ratio when RSP-SPY Ratio falls below 32% Since 2007 | MAPsignals

This is why you need to get ready for a monster reversion trade for the ages.

Normally, I’d stop here and call it a day. BUT there’s more to this story.

It gets better…a lot better.

When you single out RSP/SPY ratio readings of 31% or lower, the opportunity only increases.

Folks, magnitude is important!

Here is the chart of the week that you should share with your friends!

Whenever the RSP/SPY ratio falls to 31% or lower since 2007:

  • 3-months later RSP rips 7.4%, easily outpacing SPY’s 1.6% pump
  • 6-months later RSP jumps 29.7% vs SPY’s 16% performance
  • 12-months out, RSP jolts 57% compared to SPY’s 35.8% rally
  • 24-months later, RSP is up an incredible 92% – crushing SPY’s 57.6% gains
S&p 500 ETF Forward Return ratio when RSP-SPY Ratio falls below 31% Since 2007 | MAPsignals

Keep in mind a startling fact. RSP/SPY ratio readings of 31% or lower have resulted in 100%-win rates in both the S&P 500 and S&P 500 Equal Weight indexes a year and 2 years later.

This signal reinforces what we said last week: Now’s the best time in history to a be stock picker.

Get ready for a monster reversion trade for the ages…

Using a MAP will help you spot tomorrow’s biggest opportunity.

Here’s the bottom line: The stock market rally can keep going. Better yet, all stocks should begin to participate in the coming months…and years.

Market breadth readings indicate an undeniable truth: most stocks in the S&P 500 are vastly underperforming a handful of mega-cap behemoths.

Since 2007, this trend has rarely lasted long. More importantly, the setup is incredibly bullish for the under-loved stocks in the market.

If history is a guide, we will be looking at a monster reversion trade where the equal weighted S&P will play catch up to the market bellwethers.

Once this powerful trend begins, you can bet that MAPsignals unique data will be all over it…highlighting tomorrow’s winners today.

Just like we did with Super Micro Computer (SMCI) and e.l.f. Beauty (ELF) 2 years ago…and NVIDIA (NVDA) back in 2015…and countless others.

If you’re looking for cutting-edge hedge fund quality research, get started with a MAP PRO subscription and see for yourself the power of institutional money flows.

Don’t wait for the media to blow the bull whistle…you’ll miss the train.

Money flows will signal the green light.

There’s never been a better time in history to own a stock market MAP!

LASTLY, join us live at the MoneyShow Masters Symposium in Las Vegas as we dive into our 2024 Election Year Playbook.

MoneyShow Masters Symposium Las Vegas - Jason Bodner
Lucas Downey
Lucas Downey
Lucas is co-founder of MoneyFlows. His full bio can be found here. Prior to MoneyFlows, he was Head of ETF Sales at Cantor Fitzgerald & SVP of Derivatives at Jefferies, LLC.

16 Comments

Are you looking for new lows in the BMI index? In your opinion is a material correction around the corner?
I am expecting a tidal wave of money flowing into unloved areas of the market. That is the focal point for me.
re: 1/3/6/12/24 mo spy vs rsp \- where does your mentioned xlg fit into the graph?
It doesn't because it has nothing to do with the RSP/SPY ratio. XLG was merely a footnote to show how SPX leadership is thin, skewed to the top.
Excellent data, thank you for sharing
Thank you for the nod!
Based on this data, it would be safe to say investing into RSP ETF would give >50% return historically past 12 months correct?
Nothing is safe regarding the future. What is safer to say is plenty of stock are underperforming large caps right now. That will some day shift and there’s a great chance a monster reversion will occur.
I compared the RSP ETF (Equal weight) to VOO (S&P 500) and this is what it says below. I also looked at the chart for the past 10 yrs and don't see a period, esp after 2017 where RSP beat VOO. So are you saying this could change now, and it makes sense to allocate more to RSP than VOO? Help us understand. Extract: RSP vs. VOO - Performance Comparison In the year-to-date period, RSP achieves a 5.18% return, which is significantly lower than VOO's 15.82% return. Over the past 10 years, RSP has underperformed VOO with an annualized return of 9.80%, while VOO has yielded a comparatively higher 12.90% annualized return. The chart below displays the growth of a $10,000 investment in both assets, with all prices adjusted for splits and dividends.
A ratio chart simply takes the price RSP and divides it by SPY. A lower reading points to a relationship where RSP is underperforming relative to SPY. It’s all a relative measure. It suggests that breadth is not as strong as the market cap heavy S&P suggests. The ratio readings recently are on the extreme lower end. All I studied was prior instances that were nearly the same readings. All this study suggests is the gap should close some. A falling BMI also confirms the underbelly of the market being relatively weak all things equal. My bet based on history is that the average stock in the S&P won’t underperform this much on a relative basis. Even wilder, there is a good shot that the average stock will outperform relative to the large cap benchmark based on the favorable macro setup
The monster returns for RSP that you are illustrating are quite appetizing. Is my understanding correct that those were after significant pullbacks (after GFC and after Covid-Crash)? I have a hard time comparing those situations to the current situation. What do you think?
Yes the returns came at the lows of GFC & COVID. Those 2 periods included some of the worst macro periods in recent history. Some could argue today is a tough macro situation given high interest rates. When stocks get pummeled, eventually they spring back...the great companies.
Remember the unofficial MAP mantra... Great stocks bounce like tennis balls!
Now you’re getting it! We need to bring that mantra back ASAP
Would make sense then to a buy RSP, sell SPY strategy? My understanding is that all these RSP outperformances happened when there was some big pullback and the recovery was better for RSP than SPY. Is your +92% from the values before these crashes or from the bottom? With the above strategy you remove the common movement and just keep the differential... that would help a lot in the case of a big market downturn, because being 10% under is better than being 30% under, but still not pleasant. If I understand well your data, you would trade a potential +92% with downward exposure for a +35% with no/limited downward exposure. What about the dotcom bubble, any study? What data says about it, as I see a lot of similarities?
Hi Roberto! We enjoy picking single stocks. RSP could be a way to play the broadening theme. We believe betting on single names is the massive opportunity.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields marked *.